PiltserCowan Law LLC

Criminal Defense & Estate Law - Boston, MA

  • Home
  • Our Team
  • Fees & Services
    • Academic Discipline
    • Criminal Appeals
    • Criminal Defense
      • Domestic Violence Charges
      • Drugs and Guns
      • How to Win an Arson Case
      • Larceny, Robbery, Shoplifting, and Embezzlement
      • Larceny by False Pretenses
    • Restraining Orders
      • How to Appeal a Restraining Order
    • Wills & Estates
  • Blog & Videos
    • Blog
    • Videos
  • Accessibility
  • Resources
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Existing Clients
    • Location and Directions

Should I take the deal or go to trial?

December 21, 2015 by Andy Piltser-Cowan Leave a Comment

One of the most common questions that I get from clients in criminal cases is whether they should take a plea or go to trial. It’s a complicated, highly-personal question that you should always discuss with a lawyer who is highly familiar with your case, but I will lay out a few of the things that you should consider in making the decision.

What are your chances at trial?

The first consideration is, “can you beat the case?”  There is no certainty in this one.  I tell all of my clients that every case is winnable and losable.  I’ll discuss the more in the section on risk tolerance.  I will usually tell my clients that I think their case is “strong,” “very strong,” weak,” or “very weak.”  I won’t give percentages because my evaluation is not mathematical in nature, and I think that percentage chances are inherently misleading.  That said, I am always willing to spend time with a client discussing the pros and cons of going to trial.

In general, the stronger the case is for the defense at trial, the more attractive the plea would have to be before it is a good idea.  How you calibrate this balancing is very personal and is referred to as your “risk tolerance” or “risk preference.”  Somebody with a high tolerance for risk would take a case to trial even if their chances aren’t very good and they were offered a favorable plea, because they want to take the chance of winning and are willing to risk everything even for a small chance.  Somebody with no tolerance for risk would always take a plea unless the offer is literally the worst thing that could possibly happen at trial.  It is worth noting that a lawyer’s advice on whether to take a plea or go to trial is biased by the lawyer’s own risk preference: a risk-preferring lawyer is more likely to recommend a trial, and a risk-avoiding lawyer is more likely to recommend a plea, all else being equal. [Read more…]

Filed Under: Criminal Defense Tagged With: collateral consequences, immigration, plea, plea bargain, plea deal, trial

We accept all major credit cards as well as affordable monthly payment plans with no money down through our third-party financing partners.

Schedule a Free Consultation

To schedule a free consultation please:
Call or Text: (617) 245-1976
or
Message Us Now

Office Address:
25 Bay State Rd, 2nd Floor
Boston, MA 02215

We stand in
solidarity with the
#BlackLivesMatter
movement.


Lawyer Andrew Cowan | Top Attorney Criminal Defense

Lawyer Andrew Cowan | Lawyer Criminal Defense


Thumbtack Best Pro of 2015

ARAG

Content copyright © 2016 Andrew W. Cowan. All rights reserved.

Copyright © 2019 · Parallax Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in